Comparison of Previous and New/Proposed Criteria
(Sample of Projects Advertised between FFYs 2012-15)

DRAFT, 01/15/2016
For Discussion Only

 

Project Name Proponent(s) TIP ID Project Type MAPC Subregion MAPC Community Type TIP Year Previous Criteria: Evaluation Rating / Score
(154 possible points)		 Percentage of Possible Points (previous criteria) Previous Criteria: Evaluation Rank New Criteria: Evaluation Rating / Score
(134 possible points)		 Percentage of Possible Points (new criteria) New Criteria: Evaluation Rank Change in Rank Safety
 
(30 possible points)		 System Preservation
 
(29 possible points)		 Capacity Management/
Mobility
 
(29 possible points)		 Clean Air/
Clean Communities
 
(16 possible points)		 Transportation Equity
 
(12 possible points)		 Economic Vitality

(18 possible points)
Massachusetts Avenue reconstruction Arlington 604687 Arterial ICC Inner Core 2013 81 53% 6 73 54% 1 5 19 15 18 10 8 11
Rantoul St. (Route 1A) reconstruction and signal improvements Beverly 600220 Arterial NSTF Regional Urban Center 2014 98 64% 1 70 52% 2 -1 18 13 17 11 6 11
Trapelo Road and Belmont Street reconstruction Belmont 604688 Arterial ICC Inner Core 2012 98 64% 1 70 52% 2 -1 18 18 15 10 6 9
Canal Street reconstruction Salem 605146 Arterial NSTF Regional Urban Center 2015 85 55% 4 68 51% 4 0 21 11 17 7 12 12
Commonwealth Avenue improvements Boston 606284 Arterial ICC Inner Core 2015 96 62% 3 65 49% 5 -2 15 17 14 8 9 11
Route 9 and Oak Street intersection improvements Natick 601586 Intersection MWRC Maturing Suburb 2012 68 44% 13 57 43% 6 7 14 12 11 13 1 7
Route 129 (Broadway) reconstruction Lynn 602094 Arterial ICC Regional Urban Center 2013 77 50% 8 57 43% 6 2 17 16 12 7 7 5
Hancock St. and East/West Squantum St. intersection improvements Quincy 605729 Intersection ICC Regional Urban Center 2014 78 51% 7 56 42% 8 -1 16 12 14 8 7 6
Route 109 reconstruction Medway 605657 Arterial SWAP Developing Suburb 2015 82 53% 5 54 40% 9 -4 13 10 11 13 2 7
Lebanon Street intersection and signal improvement Melrose 601553 Arterial ICC Inner Core 2014 77 50% 8 52 39% 10 -2 9 14 12 8 2 9
Route 3 and Route 60 intersection bikeway connection  Arlington 606885 Intersection ICC Inner Core 2014 69 45% 12 48 36% 11 1 14 10 11 4 4 9
Cambridge Common improvements Cambridge 605188 Intersection ICC Inner Core 2013 66 43% 15 48 36% 11 4 14 7 10 6 7 11
Liberty Street reconstruction Danvers 601825 Arterial NSTF Maturing Suburb 2013 71 46% 11 45 34% 13 -2 9 14 10 6 2 6
West Street reconstruction Reading 601705 Arterial NSPC Maturing Suburb 2014 66 43% 15 40 30% 14 1 9 10 11 4 2 6
Route 30 and Wellesley St. intersection and signal improvements Weston 602000 Intersection MWRC Maturing Suburb 2015 58 38% 17 39 29% 15 2 11 12 8 7 0 1
Assabet River Rail Trail Acton and Maynard 604531 Path MAGIC Maturing Suburb 2015 68 44% 13 36 27% 16 -3 7 0 15 7 3 7
Bruce Freeman Rail Trail, Phase 2A Acton, Carlisle and Westford 604532 Path MAGIC Maturing Suburb 2014 75 49% 10 35 26% 17 -7 7 0 13 9 3 6
Washington Street (Route 53) reconstruction Hanover 602602 Arterial SSC Developing Suburb 2014 56 36% 18 19 14% 18 0 7 4 4 0 0 4